Maximize Revenue After Checkout: Post-Purchase Strategies to Boost AOV for Shopify Brands

Picture this: your customer just clicked “buy now” on your Shopify store. The sale is complete, but the revenue opportunity isn’t.

Here’s the reality: 68% of customers believe that a brand’s post-purchase experience is crucial, yet fewer than 20% of merchants leverage this phase. This gap isn’t just a missed chance. It’s leaving billions on the table.

While customer acquisition costs rise and margins shrink, you need to find ways to maximize your revenue. Here’s the good news: this article will tell you how. 

Post-purchase strategies like one-click upsells and AI-driven recommendations let you boost average order value (AOV) by 9.74%. And this is without annoying customers or complicating their experience (Aftersell data).

‍

Why post-purchase is the new frontier for AOV growth

Your customer’s credit card just processed. Their dopamine peaks. This isn’t the end of the sale though. It’s the most strategic moment to ask for more.

Here’s why:

1. 3x higher conversion likelihood post-checkout
   After committing to a purchase, customers enter a “yes momentum” state. Their brain is primed to say yes again, especially when offers feel helpful, not salesy. 68% of shoppers are receptive to complementary offers at this stage. Conversion rates reach 10-20% on post-purchase upsells (Aftersell data).

2. 10-20% AOV lifts for brands playing the long game
   An average Shopify merchant sees a 9.74% AOV boost from post-purchase strategies (Aftersell data). The best performers reach up to 20%.

3. Zero order abandonment risk
   Unlike pre-checkout popups that can derail sales, post-purchase offers come after payment processing. This eliminates the 86% order abandonment problem while monetizing traffic you’ve already paid for.

Why upselling works when other tactics fail

Traditional upsells often backfire. A customer browsing $50 jeans doesn’t want a $200 coat shoved in their cart mid-browse. But post-purchase? They’ve already validated your brand. Now they’re thinking:

‍“I trust this store. What else solves my problem?”

That’s why Shopify merchants like Hush see a 2x increase in revenue from post-purchase flows and nearly 10% take rate on upsells.

Let’s explore the elements of effective post-purchase flows.

‍

Four pillars of high-converting post-purchase strategies

Pillar 1: Strategic product pairing

Customers crave simplicity and relevance, especially after checkout. When you present relevant upsells, you reduce decision fatigue while boosting perceived value. 46% of customers say that a positive post-purchase experience makes them more likely to buy from a brand again.

Try these tactics that work well for leading Shopify brands.

1. One-click upsells for complementary items

Offer frictionless add-ons with a single-click purchase.

"Sell them more of what they've already bought."‍

Nick Shackelford, partner at BREZ

Nick Shackelford from BREZ reports generating over $1 million in revenue from upsells in only 18 months!

Here are some ideas for your post-purchase upsells:

• Discounted second jar of protein powder
• Matching sweatpants to a purchased sweatshirt
• A phone case that complements the phone model just purchased
• Protective screen cover for a newly bought tablet or laptop
• Charging cable or power bank for an electronic item
• Carrying case or bag for a camera
• Coasters to go with a new mug or glassware set
• Specialty cleaning kit for a high-end product
• Warranty or protection plan for valuable items
• Gift wrapping service for items marked as gifts

2. Bundled discounts on thank you pages

Bundling reduces decision fatigue — customers prefer pre-vetted combinations over endless choices. Limiting options to 1-2 hyper-relevant offers cuts mental overload. McKinsey found that 35% of Amazon purchases come from “frequently bought together” bundles.

Bundles also make customers feel they’re saving versus buying individually, even when spending more. Post-purchase buyers are primed for “helpful” suggestions.

Pillar 2: Customer-focused urgency

Flash offers with countdown timers turn hesitant buyers into decisive ones. Here’s why they work.

The science of urgency

• Fear of missing out (FOMO): 69% of shoppers buy faster when faced with a ticking clock. This is driven by brain regions linked to anticipation and reward.
• Scarcity effect: time-limited offers like flash sales can increase ecommerce revenue by an average of 35%.

How to execute flash offers

1. Post-purchase countdown timers:
   
   • Example: “15% off screen protectors – 1 hour left!” displayed after checkout.
2. Abandoned order urgency:
   
   • Trigger timers for incomplete orders (e.g., “Your offer expires in 15:00!”).

"The day before Black Friday, a brand asked for last-second tips. I discovered they didn't have post-purchase upsells enabled. I installed Aftersell for them in <10 minutes. It drove an extra $3,000 revenue over BFCM. By the end of December, it will drive over $10k in additional revenue. Best ROI on your time and app cost!"

‍Joel Padron, Steady Growth

‍

Pillar 3: loyalty-driven incentives

Your customer just bought a $50 skincare set. Now’s the time to turn them into a $150/year subscriber, but without feeling pushy.

Here’s how top brands do it.

1. Subscription upsells: the 3x revenue multiplier

Offer auto-renewing subscriptions for replenishable items. For example, Gains in Bulk offer additional savings with subscriptions.

‍

"If [my customers] buy a single pack of my product, I want to get them into a subscription. But, when I offer that subscription, my take rate is not great. So we moved from a subscription offer around the product into a "pro membership" language. It's a literal product that we built inside Shopify. Every time one of these gets taken, we fulfill it as a subscription offer. They end up with a shaker and a $20 gift card. So it's all about how you position your offer. This strategy helped our take rate really skyrocket."

Rob Perry, Noble 47

2. “Gift with purchase” loyalty builders

Reward purchases with free branded items. For example, Victoria Emerson offers a mystery gift after a customer purchases a particular item.

Example funnel setup with Aftersell

Here’s how we can tie this all together using your Aftersell Post Purchase Funnels. 

1. Purchase complete: a customer finishes buying a one‐time athleisure product, like leggings.
2. Post‐purchase upsell: check if the customer has subscribed before with the “customer tag” trigger. Then offer a “Welcome Back” subscription deal – like 25% off the first new box for your first upsell. 
3. Downsell (if they say no): there are 2 options you can try: 
   
   1. Show a smaller deal on accessories (like socks or headbands) as a one time add-on.
   2. Offer another resubscribe deal with more incentive (30% off or more) or extra products for example.
4. Thank you page: remind them they can pause or skip easily and include a link to manage their subscription (where they also see the perks of coming back front and center!). If you’re on Shopify Plus, you can also use the Checkout Editor to present these offers earlier.

By combining these steps with clear messaging, you turn new purchases (or past buyers) into happy returning subscribers. With Aftersell, it’s easy to create post‐purchase flows and highlight your best come‐back offers. When customers see variety, flexibility, and true savings, they’re more likely to rejoin and stick around.

‍

Pillar 4: AI-driven personalization

Personalization can really help you stand out in the crowded industry. Leverage AI to provide personalized product recommendations and upsells based on customer behavior.

AI algorithms can analyze vast amounts of data. Then, they can identify patterns and predict what products a customer will most likely be interested in. This can include:

• "Frequently bought together" suggestions
• "Based on your browsing history" recommendations
• "Customers who bought this also bought" options

These AI-driven suggestions can significantly increase AOV and conversion rates.

Here’s how you can use AI to sell more post-purchase:

• AI-powered single product post-purchase upsells for a spotlight on individual products
• AI-powered multi-product offers to increase product discovery and take rate
• A/B test your conditional rules against AI:
  
  • Version A: select your own products to recommend
  • Version B: use AI to determine which is the most effective for your customers

Remember: AI is only part of the equation. Focus on offering a fully cohesive and branded customer experience from start to finish. 

Conclusion: Profitability meets customer experience

We've covered four key strategies top Shopify brands use to boost AOV by 10-20% after checkout:

1. Strategic product pairing
2. Customer-focused urgency
3. Loyalty-driven incentives
4. AI-powered personalization

These tactics work because they enhance the shopping experience, not disrupt it. You're offering value at the perfect moment – when customers are most receptive.

The best part? You don't need to be a tech expert to implement this. Aftersell makes it easy for brands of all sizes to generate more post-purchase revenue. Try it today!

‍

Author: Maria Vasserman

Role: Content Marketing Manager 

Company: Aftersell

Link: https://www.aftersell.com/

Bio: Maria spends her days telling the world about Aftersell and how it helps Shopify brands make more money. When she’s not creating content for Aftersell, you can find her taking portraits around Toronto, snowboarding, camping and hiking with her dog Rocky, or jumping at a rock concert.